Debunking the Cult of Zubeen Garg


First, I would like to clarify why I am writing this. I am writing this for my fellow Ambedkarite and anti-caste friends so that they do not start believing that Zubeen was next to God, as many people in Assam have portrayed him, almost as a living God. I simply want to remind my fellow Ambedkarites that the image of Zubeen presented by Assamese Savarna media houses, Savarna intellectuals, and Savarna civil society is often sugar-coated and exaggerated. Writing this is not about denying his popularity or musical contributions but about encouraging people to look beyond the glorification and critically examine his personality and actions.

Many people refrain from criticising Zubeen, even constructively, because of his toxic fan base, whose members are always ready to verbally or physically abuse anyone who dares to criticise him. I am now critically examining some incidents from his life, and I sincerely hope that no toxic Zubeen fan will come forward to verbally abuse or threaten me in any way. I hope this because I do not want to get involved in unnecessary confrontations simply for attempting to critically examine certain incidents from someone's life.

An obituary is not meant to glorify or whitewash a person. A person's virtues and flaws, achievements and shortcomings, should all be remembered honestly. Truthful remembrance is a greater tribute to the departed soul than a polished version of their life.

First, I would like to highlight his movie Kanchenjunga. The movie was essentially against the reservation policy, and he successfully propagated an anti-reservation narrative in Assam. In the same movie, he introduced what I would call a great anti-caste theory: he split his Janeu (sacred thread) and declared himself casteless. Here, I am quoting his exact dialogue from the movie:

"I have no caste, no religion, no God. I am free. I am Kanchenjunga."

On January 30, 2021, during the Prag Cine Awards ceremony in Guwahati, he made a sexist and misogynistic comment about his co-actress, Nishita Goswami, on stage, in front of thousands of people. He publicly stated that, during the shooting of the movie Mon Jai, there was a scene in which Nishita had to walk ahead of him while Zubeen had to stay behind her and look at her. He then remarked that, throughout the entire shoot, he had been watching the actress's buttocks. He further stated that the shoot lasted for around 20 days and that he enjoyed watching her buttocks every single day. He even thanked the director, Maniram, for having that scene in the movie.

He continued making these sexist remarks for more than a minute, even as his co-actress appeared visibly uncomfortable and protested, asking him not to say anything further.

Another example of his patriarchal and male-chauvinistic attitude was witnessed in November 2024, during the protests at Dighalipukhuri in Guwahati. The government was planning to cut down several trees at Dighalipukhuri to make way for the construction of a flyover. People were protesting in various ways, including painting and singing. During one such protest, a young Assamese singer, Bishrut Saikia, was singing one of his original songs when Zubeen interrupted him and directly remarked, "Why are you singing like a woman?" (using the comparison in a derogatory manner towards women). He then told him that he should sing comfortably and freely. This incident reflects the everyday patriarchy embedded in his mindset.

In an interview with Shweta Singh on Aaj Tak, which is available on YouTube, he spoke about changing the Indian Constitution. The context of his remarks was that someone who wins an election, regardless of whether they have any knowledge or understanding of culture, automatically becomes the Minister of Culture. He argued that this was a problem with our democracy and Constitution and went on to say that our Constitution should be changed and that the time had come to do so.

Shweta Singh immediately interrupted him and sought clarification, asking, "Are you saying that our country's Constitution should be changed?" She then asked him to identify at least two things that he believed needed to be changed. However, instead of directly answering her question, he vaguely responded that everything and many things needed to change. He further argued that the Constitution should not be something that is written once and then continues unchanged for 500 years. According to him, it should be changed whenever the public wants it to be changed.

From such immature and ill-considered remarks about changing the Constitution, one can get an idea of how little he understands about the idea of India, the country's socio-political legacy, and the historical significance of its Constitution. The Indian Constitution is not merely a document that outlines how governments should function; it is the foundation of our democratic republic, guaranteeing fundamental rights, equality, liberty, fraternity, social justice, and the rule of law.

A Constitution cannot be treated as an ordinary document that can be altered according to the whims, political ambitions, or temporary demands of the public or those in power. It is precisely meant to protect democratic values, individual freedoms, and the rights of minorities, including those who may find themselves outnumbered by the majority. Constitutional amendments are certainly possible and necessary when circumstances demand them, but they must follow established constitutional procedures and uphold the basic structure of the Constitution.

There is a fundamental difference between democratically amending a Constitution and casually suggesting that it should be changed simply because someone believes that the existing system is not working according to their expectations. Before making such sweeping statements, one should at least demonstrate an understanding of constitutional democracy, the Constituent Assembly debates, and the historical struggles that shaped the Indian Republic. The Constitution is not an obstacle to democracy; it is what makes Indian democracy possible and protects it from descending into majoritarianism and authoritarianism.


In January 2023, during a public event in Goalpara, Zubeen Garg opposed the proposed creation of Kamatapur as a separate state. His remarks faced strong opposition from several Koch Rajbongshi organisations. Consequently, organisations such as the All Assam Koch Rajbongshi Students Union (AAKRSU) banned him from performing in Lower Assam and demanded a public apology for his remarks. However, the organisation later lifted the ban.

Following the controversy, Zubeen clarified at a press conference that he wanted a "Greater Assam" and did not want Assam to be further divided or any separate state to be carved out of it.

His position also raises questions about how he would have responded to the long-standing demands of the Karbi and Dimasa communities for separate autonomous states within Assam, as well as the Bodos' long-standing demand for a separate Bodoland state, for which thousands of Bodo people sacrificed their lives during the Bodoland movement.

Here, I would like to make one thing clear: as someone who was born and brought up in Assam, belongs to an indigenous Assamese family, and speaks Assamese as my mother tongue, I strongly believe that we must critically examine the politics behind the rhetoric of "Greater Assam" and "Please don't divide Assam any further."

I seriously doubt whether those Assamese-speaking people from Assam who oppose the demands of the Bodos for a separate Bodoland, the Karbis for a separate autonomous state, and the Dimasas for a separate autonomous state genuinely believe in the constitutional principles of justice, equality, liberty and fraternity.

In my opinion, such people are being hypocritical when they invoke the idea of a united or "Greater Assam" while simultaneously dismissing the legitimate political aspirations and demands of these indigenous communities. The rhetoric of "Greater Assam" and "Don't divide Assam any further" should not become convenient political slogans for denying the rights, aspirations and self-determination of the Bodo, Karbi and Dimasa people.

The unity of a state cannot be built by suppressing the political aspirations of its indigenous communities. Nor should the territorial integrity of Assam be treated as more important than the constitutional rights, dignity and democratic aspirations of the people who inhabit it. A genuinely egalitarian Assam must be founded on justice, equality and mutual respect, not on the forced acceptance of a majoritarian idea of Assamese unity.

Although he claimed to be a socio-leftist, sometimes chanted "Lal Salaam" on stage, urged people to embrace socialism, and presented himself as a follower of Che Guevara, I seriously question how genuinely leftist Zubeen was in his political and ideological outlook. Was he genuinely committed to socialist principles, or was he merely a teenager dreaming aloud and making statements to gain popularity?

How can someone claim to be a leftist while opposing reservation policies? How can someone claim to uphold socialist ideals while invoking the rhetoric of "Greater Assam" and dismissing the political aspirations and rights of the Bodo, Dimasa and Karbi communities? How can someone claim to stand for equality and liberation while displaying disrespectful behaviour towards women on public stages and failing to challenge the deeply rooted structures of patriarchy?

Being a leftist is not about chanting "Lal Salaam," quoting Che Guevara or making occasional socialist statements from a public stage. It is about consistently standing against all forms of oppression, including caste discrimination, social inequality, patriarchy and the suppression of indigenous people's democratic aspirations. Political labels mean very little when one's words and actions contradict the very principles one claims to uphold.

I just want to point out that the way Assamese Savarna media houses, intellectuals, and civil society groups have portrayed him after his death, almost placing him next to God, does not reflect the whole reality. Zubeen had his own shortcomings, particularly when it came to understanding reservation policies, caste, patriarchy, gender, and the importance of maintaining democratic attitudes and conduct in both public and private life.

The Assamese Savarna ecosystem seems to believe, and is actively engaged in establishing, that Zubeen was the greatest individual Assam has ever produced. However, no individual, regardless of their popularity, cultural contribution, or public stature, should be placed beyond criticism or treated as someone without flaws.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why Married Couples Need a Separate Shelter Away from the Husband’s Parents’ Home

SC status to Pasmanda Muslims and Dalit Christians and existing Scheduled Caste.